Charge Upgraded in Smithville Murder

Wednesday, 16 July 2025 14:39

By Geoff Waterfield

Police say they've added 1st degree murder, related to murder of Cathy Prosje

Police have upgraded charges related to the murder of 62-year old Cathy Prosje, who was found dead in her Smithville home in April of 2024.

Yesterday they laid a 1st degree murder charge against Cathy's sister, 55-year old Carolyn, in addition to the Accessory after the fact to murder, which was the original charge.

Police say Carolyn remains in custody.

Police have also charged 43-year old Joseph Vilneff, of Smithville, with 1st degree murder, as well as possession of child pornography, and voyerism.

Cathy shared the Smithville home with her sister.

Police are also thanking the public for its assistance in this case.

More from Local News

Welland adopts 2026 Budget with 4.01% increase

The city of Welland officially adopted their 2026 budget with a 4.01% tax levy increase. This equates to an approx. $78 increase for the average homeowner.
Port Colborne Man Charged with Child Luring

Police have released the Snapchat names they say he used earlier this year
Social Assistance Recipients Receiving Help

The City of Niagara Falls working on pilot program
Man Faces Multiple Impaired Driving Charges

This is in relation to a 3-vehicle crash in Wainfleet back in September
Police Looking for Stolen Wine

They say a suspect broke in using an ATV
Airport Working to End Sexual Exploitation

RCMP and Crimestoppers are also partners
Ontario Student Learning Under Review

Student standard testing results improving
Senior Seriously Hurt in Parking Lot

Police say it happened in a St. Catharines parking lot, the senior hit by a vehicle

Charge Upgraded in Smithville Murder

Share

More from Local News